Carly_Rae_Jepsen_performing_in_Salt_Lake_City_02

The Millennial Whoop: A glorious obsession with the melodic alternation between the fifth and the third

By Patrick Metzger

This week, The Lonely Island released a music video for a song that was cut from their new movie, Popstar. The deleted scene for the song, “Fuck Off,” shows Conner4Real (Andy Samberg’s Bieber-esque teen idol character) joyfully belting out the most over-the-top expression of teenage angst possible.

The song is an incredible parody, not least because Samberg and company have caught onto a melodic phenomenon that has plagued the airwaves for the past several years, which they use to great effect at the song’s 40 second mark.

I like to call this melodic snippet the “Millennial Whoop.” It’s a sequence of notes that alternates between the fifth and third notes of a major scale, typically starting on the fifth. The rhythm is usually straight 8th-notes, but it may start on the downbeat or on the upbeat in different songs. A singer usually belts these notes with an “Oh” phoneme, often in a “Wa-oh-wa-oh” pattern. And it is in so many pop songs it’s criminal.

The musical figure is probably best exemplified by Katy Perry’s 2010 song “California Gurls” (featuring Snoop Dogg):

This song comes right at the beginning of “Peak Millennial Whoop,” when suddenly every artist (consciously or subconsciously) jumped on board to replicate this earworm. In “California Gurls,” we first hear it at 0:51 as a kind of foreshadowing to its more memorable usage within the chorus at 1:05 (and multiple times in every chorus thereafter).

The beauty of such a short melodic sequence (simply the repetition of two notes over and over) is that no one can own it. Last year, after Robin Thicke was taken to court by Marvin Gaye’s family for violating the copyright of “Got To Give It Up” with his song “Blurred Lines,” Reggie Ugwu at Buzzfeed wrote a great summary of how the legal system determines whether something really is “a ripoff.” While it would be easy to claim “substantial similarity” between songs that use the Millennial Whoop, in order to convince a jury that someone was ripped off, an artist would have to prove that this “Wa-oh-wa-oh” motif was their original idea. That would put them on thin ice indeed due to the scènes à faire defense, which basically says certain musical elements are just too common to be owned by any one entity.

Ally Burnett found herself in this very situation when she sued Carly Rae Jepsen and Adam Young (a.k.a Owl City), saying their 2012 song “Good Time” had infringed on the copyright of her 2010 song “Ah, It’s a Love Song” (which starts with a Millennial Whoop). Burnett got an out-of-court settlement from Jepsen, but Young fought the case and was awarded royalties after “Good Time” was deemed an original work.

For comparison, here’s “Good Time” (Millennial Whoop at 0:04):

If it wasn’t written by Ally Burnett or Carly Rae Jepson or anyone else, where does the Millennial Whoop come from? I would argue it has antecedents in teasing songs like “Nanny nanny boo boo” and “I know something you don’t know” that, as Leonard Bernstein pointed out in his lecture series The Unanswered Question, seem to transcend cultures across the globe. It’s the kind of musical phrase that we seem to know instinctively and that has a relationship to the overtone series embedded in every single note we hear.

Also, although the melodic intervals are different, the “Wa-oh-wa-oh” syllables surely have more recent roots in the Buggles song “Video Killed the Radio Star”:

It is, perhaps, no wonder that in the same year that “California Gurls” came out, Nicki Minaj was sampling “Video Killed the Radio Star” in her song “Check It Out”:

Humans crave patterns. The reason pop music is successful to begin with is because almost every song is immediately familiar before you get more than 10 seconds into a first listen. Between the formula of European classical scales and chord progressions that have gelled over hundreds of years and the driving heartbeat rhythms that stimulate our internal organs at the right decibels, listeners are immediately hooked in by familiar structure and themes that have likely been ringing in their ears since they were in the womb. And with the pervasive nature of pop music, where everything is a remix, a feedback loop has been created in which songs are successful because they are familiar, so in order to be successful, songs are created that play on our sense of familiarity.

So it is that the Millennial Whoop evokes a kind of primordial sense that everything will be alright. You know these notes. You’ve heard this before. There’s nothing out of the ordinary or scary here. You don’t need to learn the words or know a particular language or think deeply about meaning. You’re safe. In the age of climate change and economic injustice and racial violence, you can take a few moments to forget everything and shout with exuberance at the top of your lungs. Just dance and feel how awesome it is to be alive right now. Wa-oh-wa-oh.

Here are some more examples of the Millennial Whoop. Let me know in the comments if you find any others!

Fall Out Boy – “She’s My Winona” (2008, modified Millennial Whoop at 0:14)

BOY – “Little Numbers” (2011, Millennial Whoop at 1:04)

Stonefox – “All I Want” (2013, Millennial Whoop at 2:02)

Demi Lovato – “I Really Don’t Care” (2013, Millennial Whoop at 1:00)

[UPDATE: One reader pointed out that infant-directed speech (i.e. “Baby Talk”) often uses this same interval. And a band member from Cymbals Eat Guitars (one of their songs is listed below) noted on Twitter that Jesse Lacey from Brand New calls this the “mom calling you inside from the porch interval”.]

[UPDATE: The following songs have been identified by readers since I published this post.]

Uber’s Announcement of Self-Driving Cars in Pittsburgh (2016 — Sep 13, Millennial Whoop at 0:32)

Pavo Pavo – “Ran Ran Run” (2016 — Sep 14, Millennial Whoop at 0:51)

Skechers – “Twinkle Toes” (2016 — Aug 29, Millennial Whoop at 0:00)

—-Songs above this line were released after this article was published—-

Frank Ocean – “Ivy” (2016, Millennial Whoop at 2:53)

Dagny – “Backbeat” (2016, Millennial Whoop at 0:00 as part of longer melodic phrase)

AURORA – “Running With the Wolves” (2016, Millennial Whoop at 1:11)

Berlin After Midnight – “All Night Long” (2016, Millennial Whoop at 0:52)

Oh Wonder – “Without You” (2015, Millennial Whoop at 0:31)

twenty one pilots – Ride (2015, Millennial Whoop at 0:48)

Tove Lo – “Habits (Stay High)” (2014, Millennial Whoop at 0:48)

Of Monsters and Men – “Mountain Sound” (2014, Millennial Whoop at 2:15)

Andy Grammer – “Forever” (2014, Millennial Whoop at 3:15 at the beginning of a longer melodic phrase)

Fifth Harmony – “Anything Is Possible” (2014, Millennial Whoop at 0:20)

CHVRCHES – “The Mother We Share” (2013, fragmented Millennial Whoop at 0:00, standard Millennial Whoop at 0:33)

American Authors – “Best Day of My Life” (2013, Millennial Whoop at 0:33)

Filter – “Burn It” (2013, Millennial Whoop at 1:10)

Imagine Dragons – “Monster” (2013, Millennial Whoop at 0:57)

One Direction – “Heart Attack” (2012, Millennial Whoop at 0:37)

One Direction – “Live While We’re Young” (2012, Millennial Whoop at 0:53)

The Lumineers – “Ho Hey” (2012, Millennial Whoop on the word “heart” at 0:58)

Conner Youngblood – “A Summer Song” (2012, Millennial Whoop at 1:13)

Rebecca Black – “Sing It” (2012, Millennial Whoop at 0:03)

Chris Brown – “Turn Up the Music” (2012, Millennial Whoop at 1:30)

Big Tree – “Storm King” (2011, Millennial Whoop at 2:24)

Outasight – “Tonight Is the Night” (2011, Millennial Whoop at 0:52)

The Head and the Heart – “Down in the Valley” (2011, Millennial Whoop at 1:48)

Macklemore & Ryan Lewis – “And We Danced” (2011, Millennial Whoop at 2:01)

Justin Bieber – “Baby (featuring Ludacris)” (2010, Millennial Whoop at 0:46)

Michou – “Growing Younger” (2010, Millennial Whoop at 0:37)

Alejandro Sanz – “Looking for Paradise (featuring Alicia Keys)” (2010, Millennial Whoop at 0:14

Kings of Leon – “Use Somebody” (2009, Millennial Whoop faintly at 0:02, louder 1:28)

Cymbals Eat Guitars – “And The Hazy Sea” (2009, elongated Millennial Whoop at 0:00)

Little Boots – “Remedy” (2009, Millennial Whoop at 0:51)

Mates of State – “Goods” (2007, Millennial Whoop at 0:20)

Green Day – “Are We the Waiting” (2004, Millennial Whoop at 0:34)

Death Cab for Cutie – “Lightness” (2003, Millennial Whoop at 0:32)

The Rasmus – “In the Shadows” (2003, Millennial Whoop at 0:12)

Yeah Yeah Yeahs – “Maps” (2003, Millennial Whoop at 1:24 on the word “maps”)

The KLF – “Last Train to Trancentral” (1991, Millennial Whoop at 1:00)

Baltimora – “Tarzan Boy” (1985, Millennial Whoop at 1:11)

Madness – “Wings of a Dove” (1984, Millennial Whoop at 0:43)

Morris Day and the Time – “Jungle Love” (1984, Millennial Whoop at 0:38)

206 thoughts on “The Millennial Whoop: A glorious obsession with the melodic alternation between the fifth and the third

  1. Music teachers and musicologists refer to the interval as the ‘mommie’ interval: a descending minor third that resolves back to the original note (as in F down to D and back to F). Amazingly, it’s the same interval used by children in practically all cultures and civilizations to vocalize the word ‘mom-mie’, hence the term…the use of it in today’s popular music shows (to me, anyway) the lack of creativity of artists…sigh…now I’m starting to sound like my mom…

    Like

  2. Great article!
    “So it is that the Millennial Whoop evokes a kind of primordial sense that everything will be alright. You know these notes. You’ve heard this before. There’s nothing out of the ordinary or scary here. You don’t need to learn the words or know a particular language or think deeply about meaning. You’re safe. ”

    Millennials grew up in a time of uncertainty, between 9/11, housing market crash, stock market crash and seeing parents loose jobs. They are also currently underemployed. Having “safe” music, is relaxing. It’s fun. And it helps forget the larger scale issues at hand. This is a great article that describes this situation: http://www.piggybanknomics.com/refusingtogrowup

    Like

    1. We can debate the music itself since the Sound is hardly original. But you are right about the Millennials and their context. They are the most frugal American generation since the Great Depression. Even during the postwar boom those 1930s kids had nice stuff but never to excess. It was the Boomers and Gen X that really overdid it, the latter paying big time in 2008. The Ms are quite different. Excellent point about “safe music” though the better works have always been a little dangerous, be it Beethoven, Gershwin, Chuck Berry, Coltrane, Bob Dylan or Questlove.

      Like

  3. I absolutely hate 90% of the music of today. After Eminem, it went to shit…. disrespectful, rude, terrible beats, etc. for the most part. Oh well, one day the Millennials will hate the music of their children’s era too. Not all things are good when “history repeats itself” but I certainly hope we jump back to the 50’s and start over SOON! LOL Great article.

    Like

  4. A little late to the party, but I came here via Kottke and the first song that came to mind was Brooklyn Girls by Catey Shaw (starting at 0:52):

    Not sure if it fits the pattern or not, but it sounds like it to me.

    Great article.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s